Waverly Hills Sanatorium Lawsuit

The legal battle between Waverly Hills Sanatorium owner Charlie Mattingly and the Waverly Hills Historical Society (WHHS) reached a settlement in March 2023. While Mattingly retains ownership, the WHHS gains a voice in development plans and access for historical purposes. The future of the sanatorium’s balance between commercial endeavors and historical preservation remains uncertain.

Detailed Breakdown:

Dispute Origins:

• The conflict arose from differing visions for the sanatorium’s future.
• Mattingly aimed for commercial development with attractions like haunted houses and zip lines.
• WHHS prioritized historical preservation and educational resources.

WHHS Lawsuit (2019):

• Accused Mattingly of financial mismanagement, diverting funds, and neglecting the property.

Mattingly’s Countersuit:

• Claimed WHHS interfered with development efforts.

Settlement (March 2023):

• Mattingly retains ownership but consults WHHS on development plans.
• WHHS gains access for research and educational purposes.

Reactions and the Future:

• Mixed reactions: some fear commercialization, others hope for historical preservation.
• WHHS remains committed to historical value through tours and educational events.
• Mattingly pledges to respect the sanatorium’s past and avoid a “Disneyland” approach.
• Collaboration’s success in achieving both goals remains to be seen.

Additional Information:

• Built in 1926, the sanatorium treated over 16,000 tuberculosis patients.
• Closed in 1961 due to effective antibiotics.
• Known for paranormal investigations and “haunted” status.